My wife was away visiting her friend from out of town the other day, so I ordered a butt plug to try out for the first time. I'd always been curious about what it would feel like. I had amazon deliver it on the day she was going to be gone, and as soon as it arrived I brought it in, lubed it up, and started working on getting it in. It wasn't too big, sort of tapered with a flared suction cup base. The insertion felt amazing and once it was almost all the way in I could feel my ass sort of grab it and pull it in and clamp around the tapered part. Then I went to my bed and watched some porn while I slowly stroked my cock. Every once in a while as my cock throbbed my ass would contract on the plug at the same time and it was this amazing sensation of fullness. After about a half hour of this, I finally let my self cum, and I'm not lying when I say this was the most incredible orgasm I have ever had. There were involuntary leg movements, uncontrolled moaning, literally thrashing on the bed. I can't believe I didn't try this sooner. Sadly, my wife can be a snooper, and I certainly couldn't risk her finding an anal plug (although I doubt she would have known what it was), so I had to throw the plug out that night. I'm going to be chasing this feeling again for the rest of my life now.

Good man. Glad you gave it a go. I got into using butt plugs when masturbating when I was in my 20s. Probably use them for about 40-50% of my longer wank sessions now. It does add another level of feeling.

I live alone though so don't have the same worry as you. Though it does occasionally cross my mind what my family would think if something happened to me and they fond those, my cock rings and my masturbation lotion....

Gotta love that sensation of your asslips pulsing against that butt plug....makes you realize you have ass lips!

I always cum so hard and powerful when I have my plug in.The feeling of my bum hole gripping on the plug is just amazing.