When I was a teen I thought that I had invented jerking off with an empty toilet paper tube, and thought I read here that others have tried it. How many guys want to admit and tell how they did it and did you think you were the only one?

Haha, yeah I did the same thing. I found something better though when I was a teen - a juice bottle, just about big enough to get my cock in soft, get it nice and hard and pump the bottle up and down - the suction always felt awesome - guess like some kind of primitive fleshlight.

I heard of guys using gator aide bottles guess after you get it in and hard coated with lube you then squeeze the bottle for a simulated blow job. About the toilet paper tube I can't remember using any lube back then. Guess cause it didn't take long.

Look I would never be on to brag because I always thought I was average in size...but I can only get my tip to fit down a toilet paper tube and that's it. I guess that's a good thing. I won't be a porn star anytime soon, but I think what's more true here is that a guy is always going to think he's smaller than he really is.

My dick is exactly the same size as a toilet paper tube
When I was a teen I often put a plastic bag in one, lubed my dick up with baby oil or Brylcream, and jscked off with it.
When I was done I would just flush the bag down the toilet.

Can't fit the head of my cock in one, so no go for me.

I don't think my dick is big at all, in fact maybe just slightly below average, but I could never fit mine in a toilet paper roll. Tried, but only the head could get in. And I tried this many years ago when I was a teen.

Besides, wouldn't that cardboard cause some nasty chafing?

Nope, cannot squeeze my erection into it.

That's why I've never even thought about doing it.

I'm going to have to try it again, I know it was dry and I'll measure the tube for diameter and length. Might have to try the plastic bag and lube method. Anything for scientific research.

Same here. I don't have a big cock, but I have a mushroom head that's bigger than my shaft.

Like some of the others here, I can't fit my erect cock into a tp tube, but I've managed to use one by sliding a tube over my flaccid cock and then getting hard. It's never been all that great, so not really worth the effort.

I used to do that when I was feeling horny in the bathroom and had nothing else to use. Toilet paper tube filled with shaving gel and I squeezed it as I thrusted in and out. Had to cum quick though before tube got soggy and useless.
Found better ways later in life!

Not everyone succeeded but it seems a lot of us tried. I measured one yesterday and it was 5 and 3/4 around and 1 and3/4 diameter. I am going to see if I still fit or see how loose it fits me .LOL

WTF? And I thought warm melons was weird.